Pros

  • The jokes brilliantly elevate otherwise poor movies, turning them into genuinely entertaining experiences.
  • Includes all six movies from Season 12, offering good value for fans wanting a complete set.
  • The pacing is improved over previous seasons, with better breathing room between riffs that enhances enjoyment.
  • The new cast members—Jonas, Hampton, and Baron—bring distinct personalities that add fresh humor and charm.
  • Host segments deliver authentic laughs without relying heavily on guest stars, keeping the focus on solid comedy.
  • Most movies in the Gauntlet are fun to watch and riff on, often matching the quality of classic MST3K episodes.
  • The set captures the nostalgic spirit of traditional MST3K, appealing to lonime fans who appreciate its unique style.
  • It’s perfect for group viewing and riffing sessions, ideal for sharing laughs with friends who enjoy sarcastic commentary.
  • Praised as one of the longesasting and truly original independent TV series, maintaining a strong fan base since the ’90s.
  • The new cast’s riffing is highly praised and considered a highlight of the season, adding value for collectors and fans.

Cons

  • Some movies have been edited to remove content, which frustrates viewers expecting full versions as seen in streaming.
  • The "Lords of the Deep" episode is widely viewed as unwatchable, even with the show’s signature riffs.
  • The male lead’s performance is seen as weak compared to other cast members.
  • Max’s character is underdeveloped, and the roles for Gypsy and the two new bots are quite limited, leaving some fans wanting more.
  • The ending of the last episode is unsatisfactory and feels like a letdown after an otherwise strong season.

Bottom Line

If you’re a fan of Mystery Science Theater 3000 or enjoy riffing on delightfully bad movies, *The Gauntlet - Season 12* DVD set delivers lots of laughs with a fresh cast and improved pacing. While some episodes suffer from edits and a few weaker character moments, the overall package is a solid addition to any MST3K collection, especially for those who appreciate the nostalgic charm and sarcastic humor the series is known for. If uncut versions are a must-have, you might want to consider streaming options or earlier seasons, but for a physical set offering a full laugh-filled season, this one delivers.

Get ShopSavvy
ShopSavvy is totally free and works on all popular phones and browsers
Download ShopSavvy App

Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more

Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension

Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.

© 2025 Monolith Technologies, Inc. All rights reserved..